The initial fix only covered a part of Mariabackup.
This fix hardens InnoDB and XtraDB in a similar way, in order
to reduce the probability of mistaking a corrupted encrypted page
for a valid unencrypted one.
This is based on work by Thirunarayanan Balathandayuthapani.
fil_space_verify_crypt_checksum(): Assert that key_version!=0.
Let the callers guarantee that. Now that we have this assertion,
we also know that buf_page_is_zeroes() cannot hold.
Also, remove all diagnostic output and related parameters,
and let the relevant callers emit such messages.
Last but not least, validate the post-encryption checksum
according to the innodb_checksum_algorithm (only accepting
one checksum for the strict variants), and no longer
try to validate the page as if it was unencrypted.
buf_page_is_zeroes(): Move to the compilation unit of the only callers,
and declare static.
xb_fil_cur_read(), buf_page_check_corrupt(): Add a condition before
calling fil_space_verify_crypt_checksum(). This is a non-functional
change.
buf_dblwr_process(): Validate the page only as encrypted or unencrypted,
but not both.
fil_page_decompress(): Replaces fil_decompress_page().
Allow the caller detect errors. Remove
duplicated code. Use the "safe" instead of "fast" variants of
decompression routines.
fil_page_compress(): Replaces fil_compress_page().
The length of the input buffer always was srv_page_size (innodb_page_size).
Remove printouts, and remove the fil_space_t* parameter.
buf_tmp_buffer_t::reserved: Make private; the accessors acquire()
and release() will use atomic memory access.
buf_pool_reserve_tmp_slot(): Make static. Remove the second parameter.
Do not acquire any mutex. Remove the allocation of the buffers.
buf_tmp_reserve_crypt_buf(), buf_tmp_reserve_compression_buf():
Refactored away from buf_pool_reserve_tmp_slot().
buf_page_decrypt_after_read(): Make static, and simplify the logic.
Use the encryption buffer also for decompressing.
buf_page_io_complete(), buf_dblwr_process(): Check more failures.
fil_space_encrypt(): Simplify the debug checks.
fil_space_t::printed_compression_failure: Remove.
fil_get_compression_alg_name(): Remove.
fil_iterate(): Allocate a buffer for compression and decompression
only once, instead of allocating and freeing it for every page
that uses compression, during IMPORT TABLESPACE.
fil_node_get_space_id(), fil_page_is_index_page(),
fil_page_is_lzo_compressed(): Remove (unused code).
buf_page_print(): Remove the parameter 'flags',
and when a server abort is intended, perform that in the caller.
In this way, page corruption reports due to different reasons
can be distinguished better.
This is non-functional code refactoring that does not fix any
page corruption issues. The change is only made to avoid falsely
grouping together unrelated causes of page corruption.
When using innodb_page_size=16k, InnoDB tables
that were created in MariaDB 10.1.0 to 10.1.20 with
PAGE_COMPRESSED=1 and
PAGE_COMPRESSION_LEVEL=2 or PAGE_COMPRESSION_LEVEL=3
would fail to load.
fsp_flags_is_valid(): When using innodb_page_size=16k, use a
more strict check for .ibd files, with the assumption that
nobody would try to use different-page-size files.
The doublewrite buffer pages must fit in the first InnoDB system
tablespace data file. The checks that were added in the initial patch
(commit 112b21da37)
were at too high level and did not cover all cases.
innodb.log_data_file_size: Test all innodb_page_size combinations.
fsp_header_init(): Never return an error. Move the change buffer creation
to the only caller that needs to do it.
btr_create(): Clean up the logic. Remove the error log messages.
buf_dblwr_create(): Try to return an error on non-fatal failure.
Check that the first data file is big enough for creating the
doublewrite buffers.
buf_dblwr_process(): Check if the doublewrite buffer is available.
Display the message only if it is available.
recv_recovery_from_checkpoint_start_func(): Remove a redundant message
about FIL_PAGE_FILE_FLUSH_LSN mismatch when crash recovery has already
been initiated.
fil_report_invalid_page_access(): Simplify the message.
fseg_create_general(): Do not emit messages to the error log.
innobase_init(): Revert the changes.
trx_rseg_create(): Refactor (no functional change).
Significantly reduce the amount of InnoDB, XtraDB and Mariabackup
code changes by defining pfs_os_file_t as something that is
transparently compatible with os_file_t.
Problem was that bpage was referenced after it was already freed
from LRU. Fixed by adding a new variable encrypted that is
passed down to buf_page_check_corrupt() and used in
buf_page_get_gen() to stop processing page read.
This patch should also address following test failures and
bugs:
MDEV-12419: IMPORT should not look up tablespace in
PageConverter::validate(). This is now removed.
MDEV-10099: encryption.innodb_onlinealter_encryption fails
sporadically in buildbot
MDEV-11420: encryption.innodb_encryption-page-compression
failed in buildbot
MDEV-11222: encryption.encrypt_and_grep failed in buildbot on P8
Removed dict_table_t::is_encrypted and dict_table_t::ibd_file_missing
and replaced these with dict_table_t::file_unreadable. Table
ibd file is missing if fil_get_space(space_id) returns NULL
and encrypted if not. Removed dict_table_t::is_corrupted field.
Ported FilSpace class from 10.2 and using that on buf_page_check_corrupt(),
buf_page_decrypt_after_read(), buf_page_encrypt_before_write(),
buf_dblwr_process(), buf_read_page(), dict_stats_save_defrag_stats().
Added test cases when enrypted page could be read while doing
redo log crash recovery. Also added test case for row compressed
blobs.
btr_cur_open_at_index_side_func(),
btr_cur_open_at_rnd_pos_func(): Avoid referencing block that is
NULL.
buf_page_get_zip(): Issue error if page read fails.
buf_page_get_gen(): Use dberr_t for error detection and
do not reference bpage after we hare freed it.
buf_mark_space_corrupt(): remove bpage from LRU also when
it is encrypted.
buf_page_check_corrupt(): @return DB_SUCCESS if page has
been read and is not corrupted,
DB_PAGE_CORRUPTED if page based on checksum check is corrupted,
DB_DECRYPTION_FAILED if page post encryption checksum matches but
after decryption normal page checksum does not match. In read
case only DB_SUCCESS is possible.
buf_page_io_complete(): use dberr_t for error handling.
buf_flush_write_block_low(),
buf_read_ahead_random(),
buf_read_page_async(),
buf_read_ahead_linear(),
buf_read_ibuf_merge_pages(),
buf_read_recv_pages(),
fil_aio_wait():
Issue error if page read fails.
btr_pcur_move_to_next_page(): Do not reference page if it is
NULL.
Introduced dict_table_t::is_readable() and dict_index_t::is_readable()
that will return true if tablespace exists and pages read from
tablespace are not corrupted or page decryption failed.
Removed buf_page_t::key_version. After page decryption the
key version is not removed from page frame. For unencrypted
pages, old key_version is removed at buf_page_encrypt_before_write()
dict_stats_update_transient_for_index(),
dict_stats_update_transient()
Do not continue if table decryption failed or table
is corrupted.
dict0stats.cc: Introduced a dict_stats_report_error function
to avoid code duplication.
fil_parse_write_crypt_data():
Check that key read from redo log entry is found from
encryption plugin and if it is not, refuse to start.
PageConverter::validate(): Removed access to fil_space_t as
tablespace is not available during import.
Fixed error code on innodb.innodb test.
Merged test cased innodb-bad-key-change5 and innodb-bad-key-shutdown
to innodb-bad-key-change2. Removed innodb-bad-key-change5 test.
Decreased unnecessary complexity on some long lasting tests.
Removed fil_inc_pending_ops(), fil_decr_pending_ops(),
fil_get_first_space(), fil_get_next_space(),
fil_get_first_space_safe(), fil_get_next_space_safe()
functions.
fil_space_verify_crypt_checksum(): Fixed bug found using ASAN
where FIL_PAGE_END_LSN_OLD_CHECKSUM field was incorrectly
accessed from row compressed tables. Fixed out of page frame
bug for row compressed tables in
fil_space_verify_crypt_checksum() found using ASAN. Incorrect
function was called for compressed table.
Added new tests for discard, rename table and drop (we should allow them
even when page decryption fails). Alter table rename is not allowed.
Added test for restart with innodb-force-recovery=1 when page read on
redo-recovery cant be decrypted. Added test for corrupted table where
both page data and FIL_PAGE_FILE_FLUSH_LSN_OR_KEY_VERSION is corrupted.
Adjusted the test case innodb_bug14147491 so that it does not anymore
expect crash. Instead table is just mostly not usable.
fil0fil.h: fil_space_acquire_low is not visible function
and fil_space_acquire and fil_space_acquire_silent are
inline functions. FilSpace class uses fil_space_acquire_low
directly.
recv_apply_hashed_log_recs() does not return anything.
buf_flush_write_block_low(): Acquire the tablespace reference once,
and pass it to lower-level functions. This is only a start; further
calls may be removed later.
compatibility problems
Pages that are encrypted contain post encryption checksum on
different location that normal checksum fields. Therefore,
we should before decryption check this checksum to avoid
unencrypting corrupted pages. After decryption we can use
traditional checksum check to detect if page is corrupted
or unencryption was done using incorrect key.
Pages that are page compressed do not contain any checksum,
here we need to fist unencrypt, decompress and finally
use tradional checksum check to detect page corruption
or that we used incorrect key in unencryption.
buf0buf.cc: buf_page_is_corrupted() mofified so that
compressed pages are skipped.
buf0buf.h, buf_block_init(), buf_page_init_low():
removed unnecessary page_encrypted, page_compressed,
stored_checksum, valculated_checksum fields from
buf_page_t
buf_page_get_gen(): use new buf_page_check_corrupt() function
to detect corrupted pages.
buf_page_check_corrupt(): If page was not yet decrypted
check if post encryption checksum still matches.
If page is not anymore encrypted, use buf_page_is_corrupted()
traditional checksum method.
If page is detected as corrupted and it is not encrypted
we print corruption message to error log.
If page is still encrypted or it was encrypted and now
corrupted, we will print message that page is
encrypted to error log.
buf_page_io_complete(): use new buf_page_check_corrupt()
function to detect corrupted pages.
buf_page_decrypt_after_read(): Verify post encryption
checksum before tring to decrypt.
fil0crypt.cc: fil_encrypt_buf() verify post encryption
checksum and ind fil_space_decrypt() return true
if we really decrypted the page.
fil_space_verify_crypt_checksum(): rewrite to use
the method used when calculating post encryption
checksum. We also check if post encryption checksum
matches that traditional checksum check does not
match.
fil0fil.ic: Add missed page type encrypted and page
compressed to fil_get_page_type_name()
Note that this change does not yet fix innochecksum tool,
that will be done in separate MDEV.
Fix test failures caused by buf page corruption injection.
MariaDB 10.0/MySQL 5.6 using innodb-page-size!=16K
The storage format of FSP_SPACE_FLAGS was accidentally broken
already in MariaDB 10.1.0. This fix is bringing the format in
line with other MySQL and MariaDB release series.
Please refer to the comments that were added to fsp0fsp.h
for details.
This is an INCOMPATIBLE CHANGE that affects users of
page_compression and non-default innodb_page_size. Upgrading
to this release will correct the flags in the data files.
If you want to downgrade to earlier MariaDB 10.1.x, please refer
to the test innodb.101_compatibility how to reset the
FSP_SPACE_FLAGS in the files.
NOTE: MariaDB 10.1.0 to 10.1.20 can misinterpret
uncompressed data files with innodb_page_size=4k or 64k as
compressed innodb_page_size=16k files, and then probably fail
when trying to access the pages. See the comments in the
function fsp_flags_convert_from_101() for detailed analysis.
Move PAGE_COMPRESSION to FSP_SPACE_FLAGS bit position 16.
In this way, compressed innodb_page_size=16k tablespaces will not
be mistaken for uncompressed ones by MariaDB 10.1.0 to 10.1.20.
Derive PAGE_COMPRESSION_LEVEL, ATOMIC_WRITES and DATA_DIR from the
dict_table_t::flags when the table is available, in
fil_space_for_table_exists_in_mem() or fil_open_single_table_tablespace().
During crash recovery, fil_load_single_table_tablespace() will use
innodb_compression_level for the PAGE_COMPRESSION_LEVEL.
FSP_FLAGS_MEM_MASK: A bitmap of the memory-only fil_space_t::flags
that are not to be written to FSP_SPACE_FLAGS. Currently, these will
include PAGE_COMPRESSION_LEVEL, ATOMIC_WRITES and DATA_DIR.
Introduce the macro FSP_FLAGS_PAGE_SSIZE(). We only support
one innodb_page_size for the whole instance.
When creating a dummy tablespace for the redo log, use
fil_space_t::flags=0. The flags are never written to the redo log files.
Remove many FSP_FLAGS_SET_ macros.
dict_tf_verify_flags(): Remove. This is basically only duplicating
the logic of dict_tf_to_fsp_flags(), used in a debug assertion.
fil_space_t::mark: Remove. This flag was not used for anything.
fil_space_for_table_exists_in_mem(): Remove the unnecessary parameter
mark_space, and add a parameter for table flags. Check that
fil_space_t::flags match the table flags, and adjust the (memory-only)
flags based on the table flags.
fil_node_open_file(): Remove some redundant or unreachable conditions,
do not use stderr for output, and avoid unnecessary server aborts.
fil_user_tablespace_restore_page(): Convert the flags, so that the
correct page_size will be used when restoring a page from the
doublewrite buffer.
fil_space_get_page_compressed(), fsp_flags_is_page_compressed(): Remove.
It suffices to have fil_space_is_page_compressed().
FSP_FLAGS_WIDTH_DATA_DIR, FSP_FLAGS_WIDTH_PAGE_COMPRESSION_LEVEL,
FSP_FLAGS_WIDTH_ATOMIC_WRITES: Remove, because these flags do not
exist in the FSP_SPACE_FLAGS but only in memory.
fsp_flags_try_adjust(): New function, to adjust the FSP_SPACE_FLAGS
in page 0. Called by fil_open_single_table_tablespace(),
fil_space_for_table_exists_in_mem(), innobase_start_or_create_for_mysql()
except if --innodb-read-only is active.
fsp_flags_is_valid(ulint): Reimplement from the scratch, with
accurate comments. Do not display any details of detected
inconsistencies, because the output could be confusing when
dealing with MariaDB 10.1.x data files.
fsp_flags_convert_from_101(ulint): Convert flags from buggy
MariaDB 10.1.x format, or return ULINT_UNDEFINED if the flags
cannot be in MariaDB 10.1.x format.
fsp_flags_match(): Check the flags when probing files.
Implemented based on fsp_flags_is_valid()
and fsp_flags_convert_from_101().
dict_check_tablespaces_and_store_max_id(): Do not access the
page after committing the mini-transaction.
IMPORT TABLESPACE fixes:
AbstractCallback::init(): Convert the flags.
FetchIndexRootPages::operator(): Check that the tablespace flags match the
table flags. Do not attempt to convert tablespace flags to table flags,
because the conversion would necessarily be lossy.
PageConverter::update_header(): Write back the correct flags.
This takes care of the flags in IMPORT TABLESPACE.
contains a bad and a good copy
Clean up the InnoDB doublewrite buffer code.
buf_dblwr_init_or_load_pages(): Do not add empty pages to the buffer.
buf_dblwr_process(): Do consider changes to pages that are all zero.
Do not abort when finding a corrupted copy of a page in the doublewrite
buffer, because there could be multiple copies in the doublewrite buffer,
and only one of them needs to be good.
Replace all exit() calls in InnoDB with abort() [possibly via ut_a()].
Calling exit() in a multi-threaded program is problematic also for
the reason that other threads could see corrupted data structures
while some data structures are being cleaned up by atexit() handlers
or similar.
In the long term, all these calls should be replaced with something
that returns an error all the way up the call stack.
Analysis: When pages in doublewrite buffer are analyzed compressed
pages do not have correct checksum.
Fix: Decompress page before checksum is compared. If decompression
fails we still check checksum and corrupted pages are found.
If decompression succeeds, page now contains the original
checksum.
With changes:
* update tests to pass (new encryption/encryption_key_id syntax).
* not merged the code that makes engine aware of the encryption mode
(CRYPT_SCHEME_1_CBC, CRYPT_SCHEME_1_CTR, storing it on disk, etc),
because now the encryption plugin is handling it.
* compression+encryption did not work in either branch before the
merge - and it does not work after the merge. it might be more
broken after the merge though - some of that code was not merged.
* page checksumming code was not moved (moving of page checksumming
from fil_space_encrypt() to fil_space_decrypt was not merged).
* restored deleted lines in buf_page_get_frame(), otherwise
innodb_scrub test failed.
Step 2:
-- Introduce temporal memory array to buffer pool where to allocate
temporary memory for encryption/compression
-- Rename PAGE_ENCRYPTION -> ENCRYPTION
-- Rename PAGE_ENCRYPTION_KEY -> ENCRYPTION_KEY
-- Rename innodb_default_page_encryption_key -> innodb_default_encryption_key
-- Allow enable/disable encryption for tables by changing
ENCRYPTION to enum having values DEFAULT, ON, OFF
-- In create table store crypt_data if ENCRYPTION is ON or OFF
-- Do not crypt tablespaces having ENCRYPTION=OFF
-- Store encryption mode to crypt_data and redo-log
Step 1:
-- Remove page encryption from dictionary (per table
encryption will be handled by storing crypt_data to page 0)
-- Remove encryption/compression from os0file and all functions
before that (compression will be added to buf0buf.cc)
-- Use same CRYPT_SCHEME_1 for all encryption methods
-- Do some code cleanups to confort InnoDB coding style
Analysis: InnoDB writes also files that do not contain FIL-header.
This could lead incorrect analysis on os_fil_read_func function
when it tries to see is page page compressed based on FIL_PAGE_TYPE
field on FIL-header. With bad luck uncompressed page that does
not contain FIL-headed, the byte on FIL_PAGE_TYPE position could
indicate that page is page comrpessed.
Fix: Upper layer must indicate is file space page compressed
or not. If this is not yet known, we need to read the FIL-header
and find it out. Files that we know that are not page compressed
we can always just provide FALSE.
Update InnoDB to 5.6.14
Apply MySQL-5.6 hack for MySQL Bug#16434374
Move Aria-only HA_RTREE_INDEX from my_base.h to maria_def.h (breaks an assert in InnoDB)
Fix InnoDB memory leak
written and rest of the page is trimmed. In following writes
there is no need to trim again if write_size only increases
because rest of the page is already trimmed. If actual write
size decreases we need to trim again. Need to research if this
can happen frequently enough to make any effect.
