The crash happened with an indexed virtual column whose
value is evaluated using a function that has a different meaning
in sql_mode='' vs sql_mode=ORACLE:
- DECODE()
- LTRIM()
- RTRIM()
- LPAD()
- RPAD()
- REPLACE()
- SUBSTR()
For example:
CREATE TABLE t1 (
b VARCHAR(1),
g CHAR(1) GENERATED ALWAYS AS (SUBSTR(b,0,0)) VIRTUAL,
KEY g(g)
);
So far we had replacement XXX_ORACLE() functions for all mentioned function,
e.g. SUBSTR_ORACLE() for SUBSTR(). So it was possible to correctly re-parse
SUBSTR_ORACLE() even in sql_mode=''.
But it was not possible to re-parse the MariaDB version of SUBSTR()
after switching to sql_mode=ORACLE. It was erroneously mis-interpreted
as SUBSTR_ORACLE().
As a result, this combination worked fine:
SET sql_mode=ORACLE;
CREATE TABLE t1 ... g CHAR(1) GENERATED ALWAYS AS (SUBSTR(b,0,0)) VIRTUAL, ...;
INSERT ...
FLUSH TABLES;
SET sql_mode='';
INSERT ...
But the other way around it crashed:
SET sql_mode='';
CREATE TABLE t1 ... g CHAR(1) GENERATED ALWAYS AS (SUBSTR(b,0,0)) VIRTUAL, ...;
INSERT ...
FLUSH TABLES;
SET sql_mode=ORACLE;
INSERT ...
At CREATE time, SUBSTR was instantiated as Item_func_substr and printed
in the FRM file as substr(). At re-open time with sql_mode=ORACLE, "substr()"
was erroneously instantiated as Item_func_substr_oracle.
Fix:
The fix proposes a symmetric solution. It provides a way to re-parse reliably
all sql_mode dependent functions to their original CREATE TABLE time meaning,
no matter what the open-time sql_mode is.
We take advantage of the same idea we previously used to resolve sql_mode
dependent data types.
Now all sql_mode dependent functions are printed by SHOW using a schema
qualifier when the current sql_mode differs from the function sql_mode:
SET sql_mode='';
CREATE TABLE t1 ... SUBSTR(a,b,c) ..;
SET sql_mode=ORACLE;
SHOW CREATE TABLE t1; -> mariadb_schema.substr(a,b,c)
SET sql_mode=ORACLE;
CREATE TABLE t2 ... SUBSTR(a,b,c) ..;
SET sql_mode='';
SHOW CREATE TABLE t1; -> oracle_schema.substr(a,b,c)
Old replacement names like substr_oracle() are still understood for
backward compatibility and used in FRM files (for downgrade compatibility),
but they are not printed by SHOW any more.
Adding virtual methods to class Schema:
make_item_func_replace()
make_item_func_substr()
make_item_func_trim()
This is a non-functional preparatory change for MDEV-27744.
- Adding optional qualifiers to data types:
CREATE TABLE t1 (a schema.DATE);
Qualifiers now work only for three pre-defined schemas:
mariadb_schema
oracle_schema
maxdb_schema
These schemas are virtual (hard-coded) for now, but may turn into real
databases on disk in the future.
- mariadb_schema.TYPE now always resolves to a true MariaDB data
type TYPE without sql_mode specific translations.
- oracle_schema.DATE translates to MariaDB DATETIME.
- maxdb_schema.TIMESTAMP translates to MariaDB DATETIME.
- Fixing SHOW CREATE TABLE to use a qualifier for a data type TYPE
if the current sql_mode translates TYPE to something else.
The above changes fix the reported problem, so this script:
SET sql_mode=ORACLE;
CREATE TABLE t2 AS SELECT mariadb_date_column FROM t1;
is now replicated as:
SET sql_mode=ORACLE;
CREATE TABLE t2 (mariadb_date_column mariadb_schema.DATE);
and the slave can unambiguously treat DATE as the true MariaDB DATE
without ORACLE specific translation to DATETIME.
Similar,
SET sql_mode=MAXDB;
CREATE TABLE t2 AS SELECT mariadb_timestamp_column FROM t1;
is now replicated as:
SET sql_mode=MAXDB;
CREATE TABLE t2 (mariadb_timestamp_column mariadb_schema.TIMESTAMP);
so the slave treats TIMESTAMP as the true MariaDB TIMESTAMP
without MAXDB specific translation to DATETIME.
