MDEV-11581: Mariadb starts InnoDB encryption threads
when key has not changed or data scrubbing turned off
Background: Key rotation is based on background threads
(innodb-encryption-threads) periodically going through
all tablespaces on fil_system. For each tablespace
current used key version is compared to max key age
(innodb-encryption-rotate-key-age). This process
naturally takes CPU. Similarly, in same time need for
scrubbing is investigated. Currently, key rotation
is fully supported on Amazon AWS key management plugin
only but InnoDB does not have knowledge what key
management plugin is used.
This patch re-purposes innodb-encryption-rotate-key-age=0
to disable key rotation and background data scrubbing.
All new tables are added to special list for key rotation
and key rotation is based on sending a event to
background encryption threads instead of using periodic
checking (i.e. timeout).
fil0fil.cc: Added functions fil_space_acquire_low()
to acquire a tablespace when it could be dropped concurrently.
This function is used from fil_space_acquire() or
fil_space_acquire_silent() that will not print
any messages if we try to acquire space that does not exist.
fil_space_release() to release a acquired tablespace.
fil_space_next() to iterate tablespaces in fil_system
using fil_space_acquire() and fil_space_release().
Similarly, fil_space_keyrotation_next() to iterate new
list fil_system->rotation_list where new tables.
are added if key rotation is disabled.
Removed unnecessary functions fil_get_first_space_safe()
fil_get_next_space_safe()
fil_node_open_file(): After page 0 is read read also
crypt_info if it is not yet read.
btr_scrub_lock_dict_func()
buf_page_check_corrupt()
buf_page_encrypt_before_write()
buf_merge_or_delete_for_page()
lock_print_info_all_transactions()
row_fts_psort_info_init()
row_truncate_table_for_mysql()
row_drop_table_for_mysql()
Use fil_space_acquire()/release() to access fil_space_t.
buf_page_decrypt_after_read():
Use fil_space_get_crypt_data() because at this point
we might not yet have read page 0.
fil0crypt.cc/fil0fil.h: Lot of changes. Pass fil_space_t* directly
to functions needing it and store fil_space_t* to rotation state.
Use fil_space_acquire()/release() when iterating tablespaces
and removed unnecessary is_closing from fil_crypt_t. Use
fil_space_t::is_stopping() to detect when access to
tablespace should be stopped. Removed unnecessary
fil_space_get_crypt_data().
fil_space_create(): Inform key rotation that there could
be something to do if key rotation is disabled and new
table with encryption enabled is created.
Remove unnecessary functions fil_get_first_space_safe()
and fil_get_next_space_safe(). fil_space_acquire()
and fil_space_release() are used instead. Moved
fil_space_get_crypt_data() and fil_space_set_crypt_data()
to fil0crypt.cc.
fsp_header_init(): Acquire fil_space_t*, write crypt_data
and release space.
check_table_options()
Renamed FIL_SPACE_ENCRYPTION_* TO FIL_ENCRYPTION_*
i_s.cc: Added ROTATING_OR_FLUSHING field to
information_schema.innodb_tablespace_encryption
to show current status of key rotation.
compatibility problems
Pages that are encrypted contain post encryption checksum on
different location that normal checksum fields. Therefore,
we should before decryption check this checksum to avoid
unencrypting corrupted pages. After decryption we can use
traditional checksum check to detect if page is corrupted
or unencryption was done using incorrect key.
Pages that are page compressed do not contain any checksum,
here we need to fist unencrypt, decompress and finally
use tradional checksum check to detect page corruption
or that we used incorrect key in unencryption.
buf0buf.cc: buf_page_is_corrupted() mofified so that
compressed pages are skipped.
buf0buf.h, buf_block_init(), buf_page_init_low():
removed unnecessary page_encrypted, page_compressed,
stored_checksum, valculated_checksum fields from
buf_page_t
buf_page_get_gen(): use new buf_page_check_corrupt() function
to detect corrupted pages.
buf_page_check_corrupt(): If page was not yet decrypted
check if post encryption checksum still matches.
If page is not anymore encrypted, use buf_page_is_corrupted()
traditional checksum method.
If page is detected as corrupted and it is not encrypted
we print corruption message to error log.
If page is still encrypted or it was encrypted and now
corrupted, we will print message that page is
encrypted to error log.
buf_page_io_complete(): use new buf_page_check_corrupt()
function to detect corrupted pages.
buf_page_decrypt_after_read(): Verify post encryption
checksum before tring to decrypt.
fil0crypt.cc: fil_encrypt_buf() verify post encryption
checksum and ind fil_space_decrypt() return true
if we really decrypted the page.
fil_space_verify_crypt_checksum(): rewrite to use
the method used when calculating post encryption
checksum. We also check if post encryption checksum
matches that traditional checksum check does not
match.
fil0fil.ic: Add missed page type encrypted and page
compressed to fil_get_page_type_name()
Note that this change does not yet fix innochecksum tool,
that will be done in separate MDEV.
Fix test failures caused by buf page corruption injection.
restarting server with encryption and read-only
buf0buf.cc: Temporary slots used in encryption was calculated
by read_threads * write_threads. However, in read-only mode
write_threads is zero. Correct way is to calculate
(read_threads + write_threads) * max pending IO requests.
The function fsp_flags_try_adjust(), which is called on startup,
is incrementing the Innodb_pages0_read counts for every affected file.
Adjust the result of encryption.innodb_lotoftables accordingly.
Test crash recovery from an encrypted redo log with innodb_encrypt_log=0.
Previously, we did a clean shutdown, so only the log checkpoint
information would have been read from the redo log. With this change,
we will be reading and applying encrypted redo log records.
include/start_mysqld.inc: Observe $restart_parameters.
encryption.innodb-log-encrypt: Remove some unnecessary statements,
and instead of restarting the server and concurrently accessing
the files while the server is running, kill the server, check the
files, and finally start up the server.
innodb.log_data_file_size: Use start_mysqld.inc with $restart_parameters.
Perform a slow shutdown at the start of the test, and create all
InnoDB tables with STATS_PERSISTENT=0, so that any I/O related to
background tasks (change buffer merge, purge, persistent statistics)
should be eliminated.
encryption.innodb_scrub: Clean up. Make it also cover ROW_FORMAT=COMPRESSED,
removing the need for encryption.innodb_scrub_compressed.
Add a FIXME comment saying that we should create a secondary index, to
demonstrate that also undo log pages get scrubbed. Currently that is
not working!
Also clean up encryption.innodb_scrub_background, but keep it disabled,
because the background scrubbing does not work reliably.
Fix both tests so that if something is not scrubbed, the test will be
aborted, so that the data files will be preserved. Allow the tests to
run on Windows as well.
Problem was that for encryption we use temporary scratch area for
reading and writing tablespace pages. But if page was not really
decrypted the correct updated page was not moved to scratch area
that was then written. This can happen e.g. for page 0 as it is
newer encrypted even if encryption is enabled and as we write
the contents of old page 0 to tablespace it contained naturally
incorrect space_id that is then later noted and error message
was written. Updated page with correct space_id was lost.
If tablespace is encrypted we use additional
temporary scratch area where pages are read
for decrypting readptr == crypt_io_buffer != io_buffer.
Destination for decryption is a buffer pool block
block->frame == dst == io_buffer that is updated.
Pages that did not require decryption even when
tablespace is marked as encrypted are not copied
instead block->frame is set to src == readptr.
If tablespace was encrypted we copy updated page to
writeptr != io_buffer. This fixes above bug.
For encryption we again use temporary scratch area
writeptr != io_buffer == dst
that is then written to the tablespace
(1) For normal tables src == dst == writeptr
ut_ad(!encrypted && !page_compressed ?
src == dst && dst == writeptr + (i * size):1);
(2) For page compressed tables src == dst == writeptr
ut_ad(page_compressed && !encrypted ?
src == dst && dst == writeptr + (i * size):1);
(3) For encrypted tables src != dst != writeptr
ut_ad(encrypted ?
src != dst && dst != writeptr + (i * size):1);
Two problems:
(1) When pushing warning to sql-layer we need to check that thd != NULL
to avoid NULL-pointer reference.
(2) At tablespace key rotation if used key_id is not found from
encryption plugin tablespace should not be rotated.
Analysis: By design InnoDB was reading first page of every .ibd file
at startup to find out is tablespace encrypted or not. This is
because tablespace could have been encrypted always, not
encrypted newer or encrypted based on configuration and this
information can be find realible only from first page of .ibd file.
Fix: Do not read first page of every .ibd file at startup. Instead
whenever tablespace is first time accedded we will read the first
page to find necessary information about tablespace encryption
status.
TODO: Add support for SYS_TABLEOPTIONS where all table options
encryption information included will be stored.
Analysis:
-- InnoDB has n (>0) redo-log files.
-- In the first page of redo-log there is 2 checkpoint records on fixed location (checkpoint is not encrypted)
-- On every checkpoint record there is up to 5 crypt_keys containing the keys used for encryption/decryption
-- On crash recovery we read all checkpoints on every file
-- Recovery starts by reading from the latest checkpoint forward
-- Problem is that latest checkpoint might not always contain the key we need to decrypt all the
redo-log blocks (see MDEV-9422 for one example)
-- Furthermore, there is no way to identify is the log block corrupted or encrypted
For example checkpoint can contain following keys :
write chk: 4 [ chk key ]: [ 5 1 ] [ 4 1 ] [ 3 1 ] [ 2 1 ] [ 1 1 ]
so over time we could have a checkpoint
write chk: 13 [ chk key ]: [ 14 1 ] [ 13 1 ] [ 12 1 ] [ 11 1 ] [ 10 1 ]
killall -9 mysqld causes crash recovery and on crash recovery we read as
many checkpoints as there is log files, e.g.
read [ chk key ]: [ 13 1 ] [ 12 1 ] [ 11 1 ] [ 10 1 ] [ 9 1 ]
read [ chk key ]: [ 14 1 ] [ 13 1 ] [ 12 1 ] [ 11 1 ] [ 10 1 ] [ 9 1 ]
This is problematic, as we could still scan log blocks e.g. from checkpoint 4 and we do
not know anymore the correct key.
CRYPT INFO: for checkpoint 14 search 4
CRYPT INFO: for checkpoint 13 search 4
CRYPT INFO: for checkpoint 12 search 4
CRYPT INFO: for checkpoint 11 search 4
CRYPT INFO: for checkpoint 10 search 4
CRYPT INFO: for checkpoint 9 search 4 (NOTE: NOT FOUND)
For every checkpoint, code generated a new encrypted key based on key
from encryption plugin and random numbers. Only random numbers are
stored on checkpoint.
Fix: Generate only one key for every log file. If checkpoint contains only
one key, use that key to encrypt/decrypt all log blocks. If checkpoint
contains more than one key (this is case for databases created
using MariaDB server version 10.1.0 - 10.1.12 if log encryption was
used). If looked checkpoint_no is found from keys on checkpoint we use
that key to decrypt the log block. For encryption we use always the
first key. If the looked checkpoint_no is not found from keys on checkpoint
we use the first key.
Modified code also so that if log is not encrypted, we do not generate
any empty keys. If we have a log block and no keys is found from
checkpoint we assume that log block is unencrypted. Log corruption or
missing keys is found by comparing log block checksums. If we have
a keys but current log block checksum is correct we again assume
log block to be unencrypted. This is because current implementation
stores checksum only before encryption and new checksum after
encryption but before disk write is not stored anywhere.
There was two problems. Firstly, if page in ibuf is encrypted but
decrypt failed we should not allow InnoDB to start because
this means that system tablespace is encrypted and not usable.
Secondly, if page decrypt is detected we should return false
from buf_page_decrypt_after_read.
Analysis: When a page is read from encrypted table and page can't be
decrypted because of bad key (or incorrect encryption algorithm or
method) page was incorrectly left on buffer pool.
Fix: Remove page from buffer pool and from pending IO.
Folloup: Made encryption rules too strict (and incorrect). Allow creating
table with ENCRYPTED=OFF with all values of ENCRYPTION_KEY_ID but create
warning that nondefault values are ignored. Allow creating table with
ENCRYPTED=DEFAULT if used key_id is found from key file (there was
bug on this) and give error if key_id is not found.
Analysis: Problem sees to be the fact that we allow creating or altering
table to use encryption_key_id that does not exists in case where
original table is not encrypted currently. Secondly we should not
do key rotation to tables that are not encrypted or tablespaces
that can't be found from tablespace cache.
Fix: Do not allow creating unencrypted table with nondefault encryption key
and do not rotate tablespaces that are not encrypted (FIL_SPACE_ENCRYPTION_OFF)
or can't be found from tablespace cache.
Added encryption support for online alter table where InnoDB temporary
files are used. Added similar support also for tables containing
full text-indexes.
Made sure that table remains encrypted during discard and import
tablespace.
Suppress errors about not being able to load plugins from file_key_management library.
Errors about the non-existing library are already suppressed globally.
Analysis: Server tried to continue reading tablespace using a cursor after
we had resolved that pages in the tablespace can't be decrypted.
Fixed by addind check is tablespace still encrypted.
Analysis: Problem was that in fil_read_first_page we do find that
table has encryption information and that encryption service
or used key_id is not available. But, then we just printed
fatal error message that causes above assertion.
Fix: When we open single table tablespace if it has encryption
information (crypt_data) store this crypt data to the table
structure. When we open a table and we find out that tablespace
is not available, check has table a encryption information
and from there is encryption service or used key_id is not available.
If it is, add additional warning for SQL-layer.
Analysis: Problem was that in fil_read_first_page we do find that
table has encryption information and that encryption service
or used key_id is not available. But, then we just printed
fatal error message that causes above assertion.
Fix: When we open single table tablespace if it has encryption
information (crypt_data) store this crypt data to the table
structure. When we open a table and we find out that tablespace
is not available, check has table a encryption information
and from there is encryption service or used key_id is not available.
If it is, add additional warning for SQL-layer.
