bdd0a41aed
git-svn-id: http://svn.us.apache.org/repos/asf/tuscany@668359 13f79535-47bb-0310-9956-ffa450edef68
198 lines
10 KiB
Text
198 lines
10 KiB
Text
SDO Interoperability Testing
|
|
============================
|
|
|
|
Current SDO Implementations
|
|
---------------------------
|
|
Java - M1
|
|
C++ - M1
|
|
PHP - v1.0.1
|
|
|
|
Features
|
|
--------
|
|
There are various approaches to getting data in and out of SDO and various levels of
|
|
support for these approaches across the current SDO implementations:
|
|
|
|
Feature Java C++ PHP
|
|
....... .... ... ...
|
|
XML (DAS) Y Y Y
|
|
RDB DAS Y N Y
|
|
Serialize to/from WS Y (1) Y (1) N
|
|
Serialize to/from session Via java serialize? N via serialize()
|
|
|
|
(1) - SDO->XMLHelper->String->Axiom
|
|
|
|
Given these features there are a number of basic but useful tests to demonstrate that
|
|
SDO implementations can interoperate to a reasonable degree
|
|
|
|
Tests
|
|
-----
|
|
|
|
# Test Java C++ PHP
|
|
. .... .... ... ...
|
|
1 XML->SDO-XML Y Y Y
|
|
2 XML->SDO->AddData->XML - Dynamic Y Y Y
|
|
3 XML->SDO->AddData->XML - Generated Y Not Supported Y (By Name/By Index)
|
|
4 XSD->SDO-XSD Not Supported Y Only supported via serialize
|
|
5 RDB->SDO->AddData->RDB - Dynamic Y Not Supported Y
|
|
6 RDB->SDO->AddData->RDB - Generated Y Not Supported Y
|
|
7 XML->SDO->Axiom->SOAP->Axiom->SDO->XML Y Y Not Supported
|
|
8 XML->SDO->Session->SDO->XML Via java serializable? N Stores SDO state (XML+XSD) in PHP session
|
|
|
|
Test 1
|
|
------
|
|
|
|
The test involved reading and XML file and writing it out again. The output should be compared with the input for change. The test convers all of the XML
|
|
schema features that SDO is expected to support. Each feature is described in a separate XSD as shown below. Input XML files include the test number (#)
|
|
using the following pattern: interop#-in.xml.
|
|
|
|
Feature XSD
|
|
....... ...
|
|
xsd <include> interop1.xsd
|
|
xsd <import> interop2.xsd
|
|
With target namespace interop3.xsd
|
|
Without target namespace interop4.xsd
|
|
With sdoJava``:package interop5.xsd
|
|
Global Element of simple type interop6.xsd
|
|
Global Element of complex type interop7.xsd
|
|
Element of simple type see interop10.xsd
|
|
Element of complex type see interop19.xsd
|
|
Annotation interop8.xsd
|
|
Notation interop9.xsd
|
|
SimpleTypeWithName interop10.xsd
|
|
SimpleTypeAnonymous interop11.xsd
|
|
Element Ref interop11.xsd
|
|
SimpleTypeWithSDOName interop12.xsd
|
|
SimpleTypeWithAbstract interop13.xsd
|
|
SimpleTypeWithInstanceClass interop14.xsd
|
|
SimpleTypeWithExtendedInstanceClass interop15.xsd
|
|
SimpleTypeWithList interop16.xsd
|
|
SimpleTypeWithUnion interop17.xsd
|
|
ComplexTypeNoContent interop18.xsd
|
|
ComplexTypeContent interop19.xsd
|
|
ComplexTypeAnonymous interop20.xsd
|
|
ComplexTypeWithSDOName interop21.xsd
|
|
ComplexTypeWithAbstract interop22.xsd
|
|
ComplexTypeWithSDOAliasName interop23.xsd
|
|
ComplexTypeExtendingComplexType interop24.xsd
|
|
ComplexTypeExtendingSimpeType interop25.xsd
|
|
ComplexTypeComplexContentRestrictingComplexType interop26.xsd
|
|
ComplexTypeSimpleContentRestrictingComplexType interop27.xsd
|
|
ComplexTypeWithMixed interop28.xsd
|
|
ComplexTypeWithSDOSequence interop29.xsd
|
|
ComplexTypeOpenContent interop30.xsd
|
|
ComplexTypeOpenAttributes interop31.xsd
|
|
ComplexTypeOppositeProperty interop32.xsd
|
|
Attribute interop33.xsd
|
|
AttributeWithSDOName interop33.xsd
|
|
AttributeWithSDOAliasName interop33.xsd
|
|
AttributeWithDefaultValue interop33.xsd
|
|
AttributeWithFixedValue interop33.xsd
|
|
AttributeReference interop33.xsd
|
|
Global Attribute interop33.xsd
|
|
AttributeWithSDOString interop33.xsd
|
|
AttributeWithSDOPropertyType interop33.xsd
|
|
AttributeWithSDOPropertySDOOppositePropertyType interop33.xsd
|
|
AttributeWithSDODataType interop33.xsd
|
|
ElementWithSDOName interop34.xsd
|
|
ElementWithSDOAliasName interop35.xsd
|
|
ElementWithMaxOccurs interop36.xsd
|
|
Element in sequence see interop10.xsd
|
|
ElementInChoice interop37.xsd
|
|
ElementInAll interop38.xsd
|
|
ElementWithNillable interop39.xsd
|
|
ElementSubstitutionGroupBase interop40.xsd
|
|
ElementOfSimpleTypeWithDefault interop41.xsd
|
|
ElementOfSimpleTypeWithFixed interop42.xsd
|
|
ElementOfSimpleTypeWithSDOString interop43.xsd
|
|
ElementOfSimpleTypeWithSDOPropertyType interop44.xsd
|
|
ElementOfSimpleTypeWithSDOOppositePropertyType interop45.xsd
|
|
ElementOfSimpleTypeWithSDODataType interop46.xsd
|
|
ElementOfSDOChangeSummaryType interop47.xsd
|
|
anySimpleType interop50.xsd
|
|
anyType interop50.xsd
|
|
anyURI interop50.xsd
|
|
base64Binary interop50.xsd
|
|
boolean interop50.xsd
|
|
byte interop50.xsd
|
|
date interop50.xsd
|
|
dateTime interop50.xsd
|
|
decimal interop50.xsd
|
|
double interop50.xsd
|
|
duration interop50.xsd
|
|
float interop50.xsd
|
|
gDay interop50.xsd
|
|
gMonth interop50.xsd
|
|
gMonthDay interop50.xsd
|
|
gYear interop50.xsd
|
|
gYearMonth interop50.xsd
|
|
hexBinary interop50.xsd
|
|
ID interop50.xsd
|
|
IDREF interop50.xsd
|
|
IDREFS interop50.xsd
|
|
int interop50.xsd
|
|
integer interop50.xsd
|
|
language interop50.xsd
|
|
long interop50.xsd
|
|
Name interop50.xsd
|
|
NCName interop50.xsd
|
|
negativeInteger interop50.xsd
|
|
NMTOKEN interop50.xsd
|
|
NMTOKENS interop50.xsd
|
|
nonNegativeInteger interop50.xsd
|
|
nonPositiveInteger interop50.xsd
|
|
normalizedString interop50.xsd
|
|
NOTATION interop50.xsd
|
|
positiveInteger interop50.xsd
|
|
QName interop50.xsd
|
|
short interop50.xsd
|
|
string interop50.xsd
|
|
time interop50.xsd
|
|
token interop50.xsd
|
|
unsignedByte interop50.xsd
|
|
unsignedInt interop50.xsd
|
|
unsignedLong interop50.xsd
|
|
unsignedShort interop50.xsd
|
|
ENTITIES TBD
|
|
ENTITY TBD
|
|
|
|
|
|
Test 2
|
|
------
|
|
TBD
|
|
|
|
Test 3
|
|
------
|
|
Generated interfaces are currently only supported in Java so no testing is defined.
|
|
|
|
Test 4
|
|
------
|
|
This is only supported by C++ currently so not testing is performed
|
|
|
|
Test 5
|
|
------
|
|
The test checks that the row added to the database matches the previous row in the alltype table
|
|
|
|
Loading schema and data into DB2:
|
|
|
|
From command line within the DB2 environment (you can set the DB2 environment on windows by
|
|
starting the DB2 CLP and "quit"ing from the DB2 command prompt).
|
|
|
|
db2 -tvf create-db2.ddl
|
|
db2 -tvf insertdata-db2.ddl
|
|
|
|
Loading schema and data into MySQL
|
|
|
|
mysql < createdb-mysql.ddl
|
|
mysql < insertdata-mysql.ddl
|
|
|
|
Test 6
|
|
------
|
|
Generated interfaces are only supported in Java so no testing is defined.
|
|
|
|
Test 7
|
|
------
|
|
TBD
|
|
|
|
Test 8
|
|
------
|
|
There is no consistent format for serialization across the implementations currently so no testing is performed
|